Tuesday, April 15, 2008

Fair Isn't Always Equal Chapter 7

Grades are a very relative concept. For any given paper, grades can range from A to F, regardless of the quality of student work. But a grade should be more than that; a grade should provide the necessary feedback that a student needs to improve. The reason some students thrive in a classroom setting, is because teachers are willing to be flexible, to teach in ways that the student can best learn. In some classrooms, teachers grade an A, only if a students meets the standards, while in other classrooms, to earn an A, you must exceed them. Grades are simply a personal interpretation of the teacher that, without feedback, begins to lose meaning to the student. For any given assignment, the teacher must make it clear as to how to earn the A. Expectations should not be kept a secret from the students. And, if the teacher does choose to raise the standards for an A, they must give students the tools in order to achieve these standards; that is key to a differentiated classroom. Some classrooms before to use a system of A, B, C, I (for incomplete). This may be something all teachers should consider. If feedback is the essential part to helping a student seek, then why not make it part of the grading scale? Grades a very important issue that needs to be looked at again. This article is just one example of the many reasons why the way we grade needs improvement. Students should not have their grads distorted simply to fit on a bell curve; grades are about feedback and student improvement.

10 comments:

LizBerg said...

Jess,
I really like your first link, because it has a lot of good ideas for assessment other than grades.

Liz

NickSaidThis said...

I thought that your first link on feedback was a good summary and offered ideas on what feedback is and how to use it effectively.

BethanyM1 said...

Jess, your first link looks like it could be really helpful. It gives some great tips on assessment and why it is important!

BrennaJade said...

I really liked the second like. It is a very interesting article about letter grade

danumf said...

Jesse;
Liked the article about the testing as it will go hand in hand with the chapters we read for last night.

Derek Carroll said...

really cool first link, I like how you can really go in depth with each type of assessment gathering hints and tips

Tristan said...

The second link was a really good article. I skimmed over it and I saw a lot of good information.

JuliaB said...

I really liked the article you linked it is a lot like the chapters we just read but has so much more information.

Becca311 said...

I like the first link. I think that it would be really useful to help give feedback to students in different ways.

Jason Aceto said...

Jess,
I actually came across your second link while finding links for my summary, hah!
good stuff.